groups." (my italics)
Tuesday, July 05, 2016
What is a nation?
This question is rarely asked: can
there be a nation not rooted in ethnic identity? This is considered a politically incorrect question, but it should not be.
It is not merely the land/soil, or the
culture/religion, it is ethnic identity that leads to the other
bonding elements of a nation.
There has always been the tension in
basic human nature between the individual and the group, as Edward Wilson has brilliantly pointed out, but the group is ultimately the
main unit of successful selection because the individual alone has
little power.
If “kindness” is the most important
virtue, as some have suggested, we have to take into account the
original relationship to “kin” in this word, which should bring a
check on the unchecked virtue of universalism. In real human nature
altruism has this real connection to kinship.
David Sloan Wilson said, "selfishness
beats altruism within groups. But altruistic groups
beat selfish
groups." (my italics)
groups." (my italics)
It seems to me that the strongest and
longest lasting nations managed to unite land/soil, culture/religion,
and ethnic identity. But of these it is the ethnic identity that most deeply bonds a nation and culture. For many centuries it was the
ethnic identity of the Jews which held then together when they had no
land, and their religion was grounded in the ethnic identity of the
“chosen,” which was a strong marriage preference.
Globalism in the name of unfettered
individualism has only really advanced capitalist or communist individuals bonded in small
groups.
I believe this view of human nature
suggests that ethnopluralism is the most harmonious political
structure in our crowded world of competing ethnic nations and
cultures. Ethnostates and ethnic regions can be united and protected
by a federating principle. It was the King who was the uniting and
federating principle in the past, now it can be democratic
republicanism. This is the political future.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment